The genealogically weirdest situation ever

*Return to menu

This is one of the strangest possible cases of family relationships that a genealogist might have to deal with (if potential situations of excessive inbreeding are excluded) -- I originally scanned this text in for use in debates on the Usenet group soc.genealogy.computing, as to whether it is ever desirable or necessary to record (or give equal status to) "alternative" family relationships in one's genealogical files.
The following passage is taken from The Fugger Newsletters (1959, 1970), edited by George T. Matthews: (Note that none of these people are my relatives, as far as I know!)


From Piadena in Italy, the 26th day of May, 1601

A weird happening has occurred in the case of a lansquenet named Daniel Burghammer, of the squadron of Captain Burkhard Laymann zu Liebenau, of the honourable Madrucci Regiment in Piadena, in Italy. When the same was on the point of going to bed one night he complained to his wife, to whom he had been married by the Church seven years ago, that he had great pains in his belly and felt something stirring therein. An hour thereafter, he gave birth to a child, a girl. When his wife was made aware of this, she notified the occurrence at once. Thereupon he was examined and questioned as to how this had come to pass. He then confessed on the spot that he was half man and half woman, and that for more than seven years he had served as a soldier in Hungary and the Netherlands; in proof whereof he produced his genuine passport. When he was born, he was christened as a boy and given in baptism the name of Daniel. In his youth he learnt the handicraft of a smith, which until this day he had practised simultaneously with his soldiering. He also stated that while in the Netherlands he only slept once with a Spaniard, and he became pregnant therefrom. This, however, he kept a secret unto himself, and also from his wife, with whom he had for seven years lived in wedlock, but he had never been able to get her with child. When the aforesaid Captain heard of this, he informed the Church authorities, who thereupon sent a notary to ascertain the facts and report thereon. After this event had been proved in this wise, the christening of the child was finally ordered to take place. Herr Reitner, Ensign from Wenigarten, in lieu and stead of the Captain, stood sponsor with several noble ladies at the christening of the child, which was named Elizabeth. This christening was celebrated with many ceremonies and in the presence of soldiery, such as drummers, pipers and three trumpeters. Many noted men and women in the nobility as well as five hundred soldiers accompanied the child home again from the christening. The aforesaid soldier is able to suckle the child with his right breast only and not at all on the left side, where he is a man. He has also the natural organs of a man for passing water. Both are well, the child is beautiful, and many towns have already wished to adopt it, which however, has not as yet been arranged. All this has been set down and described by notaries. It is considered in Italy to be a great miracle and is to be recorded in the chronicles. The couple, however, are to be divorced by the clergy.


[So it was claimed that Daniel Burghammer was some kind of hermaphrodite, superficially male externally, but fertile only in the female mode. I don't think there's anything medically impossible here (though I'm no expert on the subject, it seems to be a case of what is known as "true hermaphroditism") -- but the real question is how one would enter the above historical record in one's genealogy.]


*Return to menu